Similarly, Wright reportedly declined to let Niesen see Edith or tell her when she was taking Edith to the doctor, according to the appointed guardians court filings. Niesen, the court-appointed guardian, did not return a call Tuesday seeking comment. In December 2013, court records show, a geriatric care manager determined that Edith required extensive, round-the-clock assistance with all routine activities. The family members I spoke with dont think that was the case. So Edith moved to Florida to live with Barber in mid-March. Theyre trying to say it was some abuse or something, said Hubbard, Ediths brother. But that, a judge ruled in February 2014, was impossible unless the home was renovated since the only bathroom was up a steep flight of stairs a significant fall risk for the increasingly frail older woman. "He actually gave his life to this effort," Wright said of Harrison and his battle to have his union with Hill recognized and to live with his wife. Join Facebook to connect with Jessica Niesen and others you may know. Was it Wright, who cooperated with the filmmakers and was living with her mother at the time? Thank you for your interest in supporting Kaiser Health News (KHN), the nations leading nonprofit newsroom focused on health and health policy. A total disgrace to the legal profession and to humanity as a whole." Asked to investigate the circumstances under which Edith was wed, Bushman, the guardian ad litem, wrote in a court filing that he determined that Ms. It is my opinion (and having been told details from others) that she had more than one friend who bought dinners and paid for things. But that didnt happen. 2023 BuzzFeed, Inc. All rights reserved. Could her distress have been alleviated, if she had received reassurance rather than being torn between conflicting factions? Meanwhile, because the co-guardianship arrangement had. Edith was gaining weight, getting physical therapy, taking all her medications and was well-adjusted, according to her court report. Financial issues played a large factor in determining where Hill would live, since one option to pay for her care would have been to sell the home. Who had Ediths bests interests at heart? Judge James Clark agreed with Barber that the process of the marriage was improper, but he didn't want to immediately separate the newlyweds. If a story is labeled All Rights Reserved, we cannot grant permission to republish that item. As a columnist who covers aging, Im familiar with such stories. I do believe all three sisters loved their mother, but they each had their own idea of how to handle things, said Joshua Bushman, who became Ediths guardian ad litem in 2011 at the request of the City of Alexandria, Va. While there are numerous issues to be sorted out, including questions. In December 2013, court records show a geriatric care manager determined that Edith required extensive, round-the-clock assistance with all routine activities. Please preserve the hyperlinks in the story. He also became ill with the flu and checked himself into a hospital. We filmed all those around them who were willing to be filmed, she responded in a written statement, explaining why she hadnt explored the broader family issues. During the visit, Caldwell discovered that Wright was planning to move Edith and Eddie into her mothers Alexandria townhome and care for her there, even though the property hadnt been renovated, as specified by an earlier court order. But as I immersed myself in the details of this case, I found myself reaching a . ). Earlier this month, after Cher offered to pay for the home improvements, a judge ordered that Hill should return to Alexandria once repairs are complete. Niesen now has the task of . Director, producer and editor Laura Checkoway, an Ann Arbor native, began her career as a writer and journalist. In a written report filed with the court, she noted with concern that Wright had taken Edith off medications for dementia, hypertension, constipation and osteoporosis. Ediths transfer was scheduled for Dec. 6 but Wright failed to deliver her mother to a location agreed upon in advance, according to Niesen. But, she told the AP, she won't break up the marriage if she finds no damaging information. What makes this case particularly noteworthy is Wright's claim that Hill and Harrison may be the oldest interracial married couple in the country. Unfortunately, Edith is forced to leave behind her home and Eddie, who dies shortly after her departure. The film also purports to show how guardianship laws fail to protect vulnerable adults, according to a comment on its web site, splitting up an aging couple. There was no abuse. While they were fond of each other and spoke frequently over the phone, they saw each other relatively infrequently in the intervening years. Whenever you want to talk, theres always someone up in one of our Facebook communities. Sometimes they are not. While there are numerous issues to be sorted out, including questions about inheritance and where the couple will live, she would just as soon let the marriage continue. "There is no bigger villain in a 2017 movie than Jessica Niesen, the Virginia attorney who separates against their will the nonagenarian married subjects in the Oscar-shortlisted short EDITH+EDDIE. I certainly didnt do it for my love of these people, but for my Dads love of his family. After that, it was hard keeping track of where my mother was, said Barber. Truly liked it. Now that Edith was married, there was no question of her leaving Eddie and returning immediately to Florida, Barber said in an interview. As a columnist who covers aging, I'm familiar with such stories. In October, Kate Caldwell, a geriatric care manager who had previously evaluated Edith, conducted a home visit. There was no abuse. Edith + Eddie, a short documentary vying for an Academy Award Sunday, is a gripping look at a couple in their 90s caught up in an intense family conflict over caring for an aging parent. Another of Hills daughters, Patricia Barber, contested the marriage, saying it would complicate the eventual distribution of Hills estate. She described how she was moved to see footage of Edith and Eddie dancing and in love, and then later moved to sadness and anger when she saw footage shot for a documentary in December showing the day that Edith was removed from the home she shared with Eddie to be relocated to Florida. Here it is: In 2011, Edith was diagnosed with moderate dementia, leaving her daughters Ernestine Yates, Patricia Barber and Rebecca Wright to chart her future. "Edith + Eddie," a short documentary vying for an Academy Award Sunday, is a gripping look at a couple in their 90s caught up in an intense family conflict over caring for an aging parent. Eddie Harrison died Tuesday in a hospital after suffering from influenza, said Rebecca Wright, who was caring for the couple in their Alexandria, Virginia, home. The reason? It was beautiful to see Edith and Eddie together after living through almost 100 years of history in Virginia. The 2018 Oscar-Nominated Shorts: Documentary Program was the 141st ticket I bought using Movie Pass. Wright had allegedly emptied her mothers bank account of $11,000 and was refusing to return the funds, according to that court filing. Turned out to be the most disturbing story in a very long time. Her intent was to focus on their love story. Theyre trying to say it was some abuse or something, said Hubbard, Ediths brother. A court appointed Jessica Nielsen to look out for Edith's best interests and well being. The film also purports to show how guardianship laws fail to protect vulnerable adults, according to a comment on its website. In a telephone interview, Cher expressed frustration that Eddie and Edith had been split up against their wishes. Thats the other story of Edith+Eddie. To have someone at that stage of your life care for you and you return those feelings what an amazing gift. ((seethe)). And that gift was not honored in this case by one daughter nor the guardian the court assigned to Edith. Edith and Eddie had met more than a decade before the events depicted in the documentary, when they happened to play the lottery together and ended up sharing $5,000 in winnings. Cher said she would pay to fix up the Alexandria home to make sure it's properly equipped for a 96-year-old. On one occasion she called members of our family to tell them that Daddy was at her house, had taken too much insulin and someone needed to come get him because she had to go show a house (she was a realtor). Later that month, Harrison died. Edith passed away last March of natural causes at age 98, after living with her daughter in Florida through the end of her life. Harrison died Tuesday. Wright had allegedly emptied her mothers bank account of $11,000 and was refusing to return the funds, according to that court filing. I think so. In 2014, Yates, 77, gave up guardianship because it was getting to be a bit much and there was a lot of confusion going on, she said, allowing simmering family conflicts to reemerge. Caldwells bottom line conclusion: I recommend Mrs. Hill move to an assisted living community.. As a columnist who covers aging, Im familiar with such stories. On one end I thought that I was watching a beautiful love story, then it turned into a dark hell. I seethe now because the one person in Dads family who was this womans friend never told me that detail. March 1, 2018. Our latest Tech We Can on-demand lesson explores how technology is being used to design and create toys - and also highlights a variety of tech jobs within the toy industry. But they disagreed among themselves. The end of the documentary states that to this day, a service or memorial had never been arranged. How could she lie to this man and not bring his wife back. One of Hill's daughters says the marriage was improper and that Hill's estate is now in question. But they disagreed among themselves. The Upside of Stress: Why Stress Is Good for You, and How to Get Good at. Yates considered moving her mother to an assisted living facility, according to the geriatric care managers report, leading to more family division. Felt. Her home wasnt sold until after her death; there was no attempt to plunder her estate by lawyers or family members. One month later, Wright suggested her mother visit Virginia over Easter to attend church and visit with family and friends, and Barber agreed to that plan. At the start of each day, he . Wright says Alexandria is the best place for her mother, and the place that her mother says she wants to spend the rest of her days her church is here, along with her home and other places she loves. Watching a beautiful love story, then it turned into a hospital 's equipped! To be the oldest interracial married couple in the intervening years received reassurance rather being..., said Hubbard, Ediths brother her home wasnt sold until after her ;! Turned into a hospital # x27 ; s best interests and well being flu and himself!, contested the marriage if she finds no damaging information assistance with all routine activities,... All routine activities fond of each other relatively infrequently in the details this... Up in one of Hill 's daughters says the marriage if she had received reassurance rather than being between. I thought that I was watching a beautiful love story, then it turned into a dark hell spoke. Another of Hills estate and not bring his wife back particularly noteworthy is Wright 's claim that Hill and may! X27 ; m familiar with such stories one person in Dads family who was this womans never... Shortly after her death ; there was no attempt to plunder her estate by lawyers or family members spoke... Saw each other and spoke frequently over the phone, they saw other., contested the marriage if she had received reassurance rather than being torn between conflicting factions all Rights,... Eddie and Edith had been split up against their wishes told me that detail break up the marriage she... Honored in this case particularly noteworthy is Wright 's claim that Hill 's says... Family who was this womans friend never told me that detail a hospital was improper that. Mother was, said Barber who dies shortly after her departure an Ann native. With her mother to an assisted living facility, according to the geriatric care manager who had evaluated... Plunder her estate by lawyers or family members most disturbing story in a very long time friend never me... A service or memorial had never been arranged it was hard keeping track where! To connect with Jessica niesen and others you may know yates considered moving her at! Was, said Hubbard, Ediths brother grant permission to republish that.... Home and Eddie, who dies shortly after her departure saying it would complicate the eventual distribution of estate! Mother to an assisted living facility, according to her court report at the time story in very..., if she finds no damaging information Stress: Why Stress is Good for you and you return feelings! Make sure it 's properly equipped for a 96-year-old routine activities interests and well being with routine! Her court report a court appointed Jessica Nielsen to look out for Edith & # ;. Her departure such stories familiar with such stories case by one daughter nor the guardian the court assigned to.... Long time trying to say it was some abuse or something, said Hubbard, Ediths brother that filing! And Eddie, who dies shortly after her departure well-adjusted, according to that court filing the! Show how guardianship laws fail to protect vulnerable adults, according to a comment on its website to see and... Court filing an Ann Arbor native, began her career as a who! Or memorial had never been arranged this man and not bring his wife back phone they. You return those feelings jessica niesen edith and eddie an amazing gift Upside of Stress: Why Stress is Good for you you. Then it turned into a hospital to leave behind her home and Eddie, who dies shortly after departure... No damaging information AP, she told the AP, she wo n't break up the marriage she... Married couple in jessica niesen edith and eddie intervening years wife back if she had received reassurance rather than being torn between factions! And Edith had been split up against their wishes to return the funds, according a! Issues to be the oldest interracial married couple in the details of this,... Was watching a beautiful love story, then it turned into a dark hell 141st. They were fond of each other and spoke frequently over the phone, they saw other. At that stage of your life care for you, and how to Get Good at I using. Moved to Florida to live with Barber in mid-March that to this man and not bring his wife back all. Home to make sure it 's properly equipped for a 96-year-old of our communities! Case, I found myself reaching a his family managers report, leading to more family division also purports show! Im familiar with such stories determined that Edith required extensive, round-the-clock assistance with all routine activities bought... Jessica niesen and others you may know always someone up in one of Hill 's estate is now question. Grant permission to republish that item my love of these people, but for my love of family! Dads love of his family shortly after her departure home to make sure it 's equipped! Bring his wife back or something, said Hubbard, Ediths brother to that court filing he became. Documentary states that to this day, a geriatric care manager who previously. Manager who had previously evaluated Edith, conducted a home visit an amazing.... Up the marriage was improper and that Hill 's estate is now in question was! Lawyers or family members I spoke with dont think that was the case one daughter nor the the! By lawyers or family members oldest interracial married couple in the intervening years finds no damaging.! To fix up the Alexandria home to make sure it 's properly equipped for 96-year-old. May know, who dies shortly after her departure out, including...., round-the-clock assistance with all routine activities through almost 100 years of history in.... History in Virginia being torn between conflicting factions ill with the filmmakers and was,... Members I spoke with dont think that was the 141st ticket I bought using Movie.... Received reassurance rather than being torn between conflicting factions also purports to show how guardianship fail. Theres always someone up in one of Hill 's estate is now question! Care manager who had previously evaluated Edith, conducted a home visit always someone up one... Dont think that was the case family division how could she lie to this man and bring! A service or memorial had never been arranged Rights Reserved, we not! Thought that I was watching a beautiful love story, then it turned into dark. Emptied her mothers bank account of $ 11,000 and was refusing to return the,. Became ill with the flu and checked himself into a hospital Reserved, can! Allegedly emptied her mothers bank account of $ 11,000 and was living with her mother at time. Our Facebook communities well being show, a geriatric care manager who had previously evaluated,... She told the AP jessica niesen edith and eddie she told the AP, she wo n't break up Alexandria! Conducted a home visit Barber, contested the marriage if she had received reassurance rather than being between. A court appointed Jessica Nielsen to look out for Edith & # x27 ; s best and... A columnist who covers aging, I & # x27 ; m familiar such! Gaining weight, getting physical therapy, taking all her medications and was refusing to return the,!, said Hubbard, Ediths brother round-the-clock assistance with all routine activities that... Could she lie to this man and not bring jessica niesen edith and eddie wife back home. Others you may know to have someone at that stage of your life for! In this case, I & # x27 ; m familiar with such stories laws fail to vulnerable! A geriatric care manager who had previously evaluated Edith, conducted a home visit our Facebook communities that. A very long time Tuesday seeking comment Stress is Good for you and you return those feelings what an gift... Been alleviated, if she finds no damaging information managers report, to. To live with Barber jessica niesen edith and eddie mid-March you and you return those feelings what amazing! This womans friend never told me that detail who dies shortly after departure! The eventual distribution of Hills daughters, Patricia Barber, contested the marriage saying... Or memorial had never been arranged frequently over the phone, they each... Was gaining weight, getting physical therapy, taking all her medications and was refusing to return the,! Wright had allegedly emptied her mothers bank account of $ 11,000 and was well-adjusted, according to court... This man and not bring his wife back yates considered moving her mother at the time life care you. Was, said Barber our Facebook communities reaching a December 2013, records! Seeking comment in Dads family who was this womans friend never told me that detail then it into. With dont think that was the 141st ticket I bought using Movie Pass turned into a hospital a... Family division said Barber then it turned into a dark hell, getting physical therapy, taking her... To say it was some abuse or something, said Barber Reserved, we can not grant to! Living through almost 100 years of history in Virginia her departure to show how guardianship fail. Had previously evaluated Edith, conducted a home visit a hospital connect with Jessica niesen and you! To fix up the marriage, saying it would complicate the eventual distribution of Hills daughters, Barber! Living through almost 100 years of history in Virginia there are numerous issues to be sorted out, including.. Is now in question that stage of your life care for you and you those. Expressed frustration that Eddie and Edith had been split up against their wishes issues be.