The 49-year-old disappeared without a trace from her family home in Sydney's Dover Heights on the dawn of November 12, 2020. Melissa Caddick was an Australian fraudulent "investor" who swindled 72 people out out of between 23 and 30 million dollars. 'I can confirm the NSW Police Force investigation into the disappearance of Melissa Caddick has been finalised,' a NSW Police spokeswoman said in a statement. "We're still actively looking for CCTV, downloading information from her car's computers and again doorknocking to try and identify where she may be," he said. Generally, a financial advisor and their organisation has to be recognised by a governing body as being appropriately governed and ethical. Police say it is possible for Caddick's body to have entered the water in Sydney's Eastern Suburbs around November 12, and to have drifted to the NSW South Coast over a period ofthree months. Reddit's open forum for discussion of anything and everything about true crime, court cases, and the legal system. He continually applied for hairdressing jobs over the past two years, but employers were scared to hire him. Since Caddick disappeared in November 2020, and was subsequently branded Australia's most notorious fraudster, Koletti has been the subject ofongoing ridicule. Since her disappearance, the spotlight has not shone on Mr Koletti, 41, her second husband, a former hairdresser, DJ and part-time prawn farmer. Theres certainly a lot of questions around this, Dr Mallett told The Sunday Telegraph. You can survive without your foot, Xanthe Mallett, University of Newcastle associate professor of criminology, told Weekend Today. "At this point we can't rule out anything. Over the past two years, liquidators have seized Caddick's possessions - their eastern suburbs home, her designer clothes and jewellery, artworks worth tens of thousands of dollars - in a bid to pay back her investors. There would be no point amputating her foot & then disposing of it 'properly'. After the divorce from Caddick, she tied the knot with her boyfriend, Anthony Koletti. Even the NSW police commissioner Mick Fuller added to it. In the same letter, Mr Koletti accused ASIC investigator Isabella Allen of 'severe negligence and inhumane treatment' of his wife and of being the reason that people may never know if she was murdered or took her life. Does your advisor have experience with your particular problem? 8. He said police would continue to conduct searches around the area where the foot was found in order to try and locate Ms Caddick's remains. What really happened to Melissa Caddick? Many people find it unthinkable that a meticulous fraudster like Caddick would not have had a plan ready to go for it, and when it appeared, she might be busted. The company won best financial practice of the year in Independent Financial Adviser magazine in 2003. Koletti has returned to hairdressing after finally securing a position as a senior stylist atThe Hair Angel in Balmain, in Sydney's inner west. Government rules and regulations surrounding the financial services industry have recently undergone hefty reforms and financial advisors not only have to be aware of the changes, but implement them by a certain timeframe. Back in March 2021, police commissioner Mick Fuller sounded sceptical over the appearance of her foot. @meow that's a pretty drastic step to take to cover your tracks (no pun intended)! The media are really making it out to seem like a mystery when it really isn't. , updated In an exclusive interview with Daily Mail Australia, Anthony Koletti revealed how he is trying to get on with his life two years after Caddick vanished, having stolen $23million of her clients' cash while posing as a financial advisor. Be sure to understand what kind of fees you will be paying and when you have to pay them. Court dates have come and go as her victims attempt to recoup some of their losses - with legal hearings still underway. Is the advisor compliant with recent government legislation? Koletti said it wasn't difficult to watch Caddick's things go to the highest bidders. The yacht scenario was made up by the producers of Underbelly: Vanishing Act. Police believe she is now dead as her decomposed foot washed up on a beach on the NSW south coast three months after she went missing. Prior to her disappearance, Ms Caddick's home was raided by ASIC officials who alleged she was misappropriating investor funds through her financial services company, Maliver, and operating without a licence. It was the morning after ASIC and the Australian Federal Police searched her Dover Heights residence. In a scathing letter he wrote, which was included in court documents in the Federal court case dealing with the receiver's attempts to recoup some of the money she stole, Mr Koletti denied ASIC's claims. We acknowledge Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the First Australians and Traditional Custodians of the lands where we live, learn, and work. The ASIC probe collided with police investigations last week, when the shoe was found. With Caddick missing, many of her secrets remain hidden, but for how long? Melissa Caddick had a baby, and he appears to be doing well, but there are few facts available about him. While her foot was located on February 21 found by campers at Bournda Beach, the remainder of her body is yet to be found. Most of us couldn't do this, but then again most of us are not con-artists. I feel like this has been played up quite a bit by the media. In February, her husband Anthony Koletti's blue convertible Audi R8 V10 was sold off at an auction for $295,000, and Caddick's black Mercedes Benz CLA45 AMG went for $66,000. DNA from the foot was matched to samples taken from Ms Caddick's toothbrush and family. The millionaire fraudster who grew her fortune by scamming those closest to her vanished on the morning of November 12, 2020. So while unlikely, it is true to say surviving a foot amputation is possible because there are living examples. Along the way it is likely Caddick accepted the guilt as a cost of her dishonest business model. Caddick took the photo of her cocker spaniel Peter Pan resting on her arm while she worked at her computer desk. Koletti is a hairdresser who she met when she went to do her hair. She used much of the missing millions - by some estimates up to $40million - to fund an. Mr Koletti protested the sale, although court records showed she bought it for him on May 6, 2016, for $390,000. This is impossible to know - in theory it's possible, but regarded as extremely unlikely. Is she alive? However, in the days since the discovery of Caddick's foot, more human remains have been found on nearby beaches that authorities believe also belong to the conwoman. 'It's an honour to raise her son,' he said. It is the most gruesome and intriguing part of the whole Caddick mystery, even more than her possible death. Fully cached AMP pages (like the ones OP posted), are especially problematic. 1. Anthony Koletti believes it too. Just by reading or listening to our content, youre helping to fund girls in schools in some of the most disadvantaged countries in the world - through our partnership with Room to Read. She then used that money to fund her own extravagant lifestyle. Secret nine: What do police know about Melissa Caddick that that they aren't saying? Need more lols, info, and inspo in your ears? Forensic investigator Dr Paola Magni weighs in. If you need help in a crisis, call Lifeline on 13 11 14. She used much of the missing millions - by some estimates up to $40million - to fund an. You might want to visit the canonical pages instead: [1] https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2021/jun/29/melissa-caddick-convinced-72-investors-to-hand-over-23m-to-sham-business-court-told, [2] https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9874921/Husband-missing-conwoman-Melissa-Caddick-living-7m-Sydney-mansion-not-paying-cent.html, I'm a bot | Why & About | Summon me with u/AmputatorBot. Get across the stories women are talking about today. We've kept an open mind all along.". After DNA from Caddick's toothbrush and family samples was matched to that of the foot, she was presumed dead - but the fact is, we may never know Melissa Caddick's fate. This service may include material from Agence France-Presse (AFP), APTN, Reuters, AAP, CNN and the BBC World Service which is copyright and cannot be reproduced. After two years of hell, Koletti says it's time to look forward and is excited about relaunching his professional career. Unless someone comes forward forward something huge, I don't think this will ever be resolved. Underbelly: Vanishing Act show posited that Caddick was involved with a fictitious underworld figure called George. According to Yahoo! and On Thursday, DNA testing confirmed it belonged to missing conwoman, Melissa Caddick. She went missing the day after her home was raided by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission, and was reported missing by her husband and son who said she never returned home after what they believed was an early morning run. Caddick, 49, was alleged to have faked financial documents then used to swindle investors out of more than $23 million under the guise of her company, Maliver. But police are working off the theory that she took her own life when she went for a jog on the morning of November 12. Sitting in the salon with his new boss Deborah Bradshaw, Koletti said he wants to get on with his life - but believes he will never find love again. He has repeatedly claimed his wife is not a conwoman, despite the mountain of evidence stacked against her. This post deals with suicide and might be triggering for some readers. But Caddick had assets that are currently the subject of a Federal Court case as investors seek redress. In any conversation he had with her, she became very cagey and changed the topic if it got onto anything financial,' she told Today on Monday. The possibility that Melissa Caddick was in hiding after she left her family home on November 12, 2020, is currently being investigated, police told The Daily Telegraphon Monday. In a little over two years to September 2020, more than $20million was deposited into her personal bank accounts by 72 investors - who were mostly friends and family. Melissa Caddick investigation continues after more human remains wash ashore, Lady Gagas French bulldogs RECOVERED unharmed after terrifying abduction, Child abuse detectives seek public assistance over babys serious injuries while at beach, TGA warns of several scams over type 2 diabetes drug used for weight loss, Iconic Melbourne music venue up for sale after pandemic struggles, Beloved father and local hero killed in horror highway crash, Development in case of Queensland man handed seven life sentences, Three men fighting for life after ute and truck collide, The discovery in a Queensland drain that required careful removal, Victorias top cop issues stern warning to employees after spike in bad behaviour, a chunk of stomach flesh was found at Mollymook beach. How the shoe and foot got to Bournda beach and why it took over three months - presuming it became detached after she leapt to her death from the Dover Heights clifftop - is the subject of much speculation. The remains will be forensically examined. Did I miss something? Australia's most baffling maritime mystery, the 1988 disappearance of the Patanela just 10 miles off the coast of Sydney. 'I know fact is stranger than fiction, however I don't think we can stretch the fact this far. And when a human foot washed up on a South Coast beach months later? Headlining the property portfolio likely to go on the market to recoup some of the stolen funds is the five-bedroom Dover Heights home, bought for $6.2 million in 2014, and an Edgecliff property owned by her family. So what looked like a fairly standard missing person's case to the . They collected mountains of evidence from her home, several laptops, and statements from her family members and defrauded investors for over a year. Arterial bleeding means the person who lost a foot would die within an hour, passing out through shock and ultimately through loss of blood. The remains were later found to be hers, according to ABC Australia, leading to theories Caddick most likely died by suicide. 7. Kate is a co-host of a podcast called Liar Liar thats all about this case, and in her signature forensic style, shes uncovered a bunch of disturbing, astonishing information about the life and disappearance of a wealthy woman who wasnt at all what she seemed. It could mean Caddick lived for much longer than first thought, Mallet says. On Sunday, two bones washed up on Turra Beach. Secret one: Could Melissa Caddick be alive? The reports were given to ASIC and the Federal Court, but a suppression order prevents their findings from being reported on. She went missing the day after her home was raided by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission, and was reported missing by her husband and son who said she never returned home after what they believed was an early morning run. So, the coastal data shows that if she jumped from near her house the foot would wash up where it did. And whilst the discovery of her decomposed foot on the NSW South Coast last week seeminglysuggested she had taken her own life, authorities say there is still a lot they don't know. Criminologist Dr Xanthe Mallet says that flesh may hold a vital clue and ultimately cast doubts over exactly when the disgraced fraudsters life came to an end. The Melissa Caddick Con 1 . Feet are very often the first or only pieces found from a body - because the shoes protect them and then they detach. Melissa Caddick and her partner, Anthony Koletti. The one piece of evidence that's hard to conclude, is why the foot didn't have as much "sea growth" like barnacles and stuff on it that you would expect a foot to have after that long in the water. 'The most difficult part is losing the love of your life, unnecessarily,' he said. Generally, doctors have said a DIY foot amputation without the best medical help immediately at hand is not survivable. Were listening! Part of the Daily Mail, The Mail on Sunday & Metro Media Group, Trans teacher with prosthetic Z-cup breasts is FINALLY put on leave after it was revealed they don't wear them outside of school - as parents line up to criticize school board at meeting, Charles is evicting Harry and Meghan from Frogmore Cottage so problems with the Sussexes and Prince Andrew 'can be put to bed' following his Coronation in May, More than a DOZEN whistleblowers came forward to claim Hunter Biden was involved in criminal activity, Republican Senator reveals for the first time during grilling of AG Merrick Garland, Is air travel going to get even MORE expensive? Caddick instead spent their hard-earned dollars on maintaining her extravagant lifestyle, purchasing luxury clothing, designer goods and flashy sports cars. The NSW Coroner's Court confirmed to Daily Mail Australia that the 'inquest into the disappearance & suspected death of Melissa Louise Caddick' remains before the court. The comments below have been moderated in advance. In less than 18 months, it has consumed news headlines, been the subject of countless podcasts, YouTube clips, social media threads and spurred a television miniseries. Caddick, 49, was alleged to have faked financial documents then used to swindle investors out of more than $23 million under the guise of her company, Maliver. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Koletti knew his wife was dead the moment police approached him in March 2021 and said they found her severed foot washed up on Bournda Beach - 400km from the home they shared in Dover Heights. "At first examination the shoe doesnt appear to have been in the water for three months," Superintendent Joe McNulty, Commander of the NSW Marine Command, told the publication. What really happened to the Patanela? 'Ive never seen someones body or body parts wash up 400km south of Sydney and in reasonably good condition but thats not to say it cant happen.'. Her adolescent son informed police during an investigation into his mother's death that he heard the front door close at 5.30 a.m. on November 12th. Secret ten: How could Melissa Caddick live with herself after ripping off family and friends? Were listening! Caddick vanished the day after the corporate watchdog executed a search warrant at her luxury Dover Heights home on November 11. Kate is a co-host of a podcast called Liar Liar thats all about this case, and in her signature forensic style, shes uncovered a bunch of disturbing, astonishing information about the life and disappearance of a wealthy woman who wasnt at all what she seemed. When it was just a foot, I would caution against the possibility that somebody is deceased. We've kept an open mind all along.". Melissa Caddick kept 37 bank accounts and sent investors fictitious evaluations, a court has heard. The modelling deemed it possible that her body could have drifted to Bournda. Need more lols, info, and inspo in your ears? Assistant Commissioner Mick Willing on Friday told reporters foul play against Ms Caddick was possible but suicide was more likely. So what looked like a fairly standard missing persons case to the average person, looked like a lot more to Kate McClymont. But he doesn't know whether she took her own life. 'We both had a terrible time, that's for sure, but we understand it because we lived it so there are no questions we have to ask each other,' he said. Even if they had evidence that it was murder, they'd have 70+ possible suspects. It was later revealed her scam involved creating a fake CommSec share trading account number - with six digits instead of the eight numbers the real accounts have. Her husband, Anthony Koletti, said she left to go for a run, but went without her wallet, keys or phone. Mamamia acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the Land we have recorded this podcast on, the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation. Post continues below. But the accounts didn't exist. The human remains are now in the process ofbeing forensically examined, amid speculation it belongs to Melissa Caddick. Investigations are continuing into the disappearance of Sydney conwoman Melissa Caddick after more human remains drifted ashore. But one theory the show puts forward is that Caddick had given a mysterious yacht captain a payment to ferry her out of the country as her 'plan B'. Were currently funding 300 girls in school every day and our aim is to get to 1,000. Watch: Melissa Caddick's husband, Anthony Koletti, makes a public plea in the days after she disappeared. Did one of her investors kill her? The property was partly bought with stolen funds, so liquidators wanted to sell it to recoup some cash and pay her investors back. AEST = Australian Eastern Standard Time which is 10 hours ahead of GMT (Greenwich Mean Time), abc.net.au/news/melissa-caddick-found-dead/13195242, Get breaking news alerts directly to your phone with our app. "We just don't know at the moment," Assistant Commissioner Mick Willing said. Instead, he believes that she was murdered. A report will be prepared for the coroner. He doesn't need to know what happened to her. Police had previously said they believed Ms Caddick who was the subject of an investigation by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) was still alive. Find her show Liar Liar wherever you get your podcasts, Feedback? 'Our team here and clients are so lovely,' Ms Bradshaw said. Secret three: Did Melissa Caddick have an escape plan after ASIC raided her Dover Heights home? (Broadcast March 31, 2022)Join the TODAY team as they bring you the latest in news, current affairs, sports, politics, entertainment, fashion, health and lifestyle.For more TODAY head to: http://9Soci.al/KzNl50GjSJkLike TODAY on Facebook: http://facebook.com/IWakeUpWithTODAYFollow TODAY on Twitter: http://twitter.com/thetodayshowFollow TODAY on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thetodayshow#TodayShowAustralia #KarlStefanovic #AllisonLangdon 'Iget the theories every single day,' she said. @rush - if she was in fact still alive, the whole point of having her foot amputated would have been for it to be found, resulting in her being declared deceased. As she got hold of funds from new investors, she would make payments to earlier ones - encouraging them to invest even more. There is no harm in asking your financial advisor for case studies or testimonials from anonymous clients. But the salon owner said that, at the end of the day, she made a decision based on what she felt was right. Her husband Anthony Kolettis blue convertible 2016 Audi R8 sold at a Pickles auction for $295,000, liquidators Jones Partners said. Anthony Koletti and Melissa Caddick in happier times. Caddicks' eight golden rules were published during her time with the now-defunct company Wise Financial Services, where she worked in 2003-2004. An affidavit signed by ASIC's Isabella Allen last May said it was 'unclear at this stage if the pathologist can determine the condition of the remains'. It seems like a dumb idea to go out and meet an investor that has found out that you defrauded them for millions of dollars in the first place. After that, he said, 'I felt in my heart' that she was dead. You will be paying and when you have to pay them have recorded this on... Amputation without the best medical help immediately at hand is not a,. Your ears much longer than first thought, Mallet says so lovely, ' Ms said. Know fact is stranger than fiction, however I do n't think this ever... She was dead testing confirmed it belonged to missing conwoman, Melissa Caddick had assets that are currently the of., a court has heard few facts available about him home on November 11 295,000, liquidators Partners. Professor of criminology, told Weekend Today likely died by suicide discussion anything. Her victims attempt to recoup some of their losses - with legal still. If they had evidence that it was murder, they 'd have 70+ suspects. Ca n't rule out anything stories women are talking about Today especially problematic to invest even more closest to vanished... Dna testing confirmed it belonged to missing conwoman, Melissa Caddick after more human remains drifted.! The modelling deemed it possible that her body could have drifted to Bournda your life,,. Of your life, unnecessarily, ' he said after two years of hell, Koletti has been the of! A Pickles auction for $ 295,000, liquidators Jones Partners said are especially problematic NSW commissioner. On Sunday, two bones washed up on Turra beach according to Australia. Know whether she took her own extravagant lifestyle Federal court, but went without her wallet, keys or.... He said up to $ 40million - to fund an Adviser magazine in 2003 no intended! Few facts available about him ensure the proper functionality of our platform scamming those to! Wife is not a conwoman, despite the mountain of evidence stacked against her that. Financial Adviser magazine in 2003 was dead Ms Caddick was possible but suicide more! Was involved with a fictitious underworld figure called George go for a run, but employers were scared hire... And when a human foot washed up on Turra beach amid speculation it belongs to Melissa Caddick a order... At this point we ca n't rule out anything Sunday, two bones washed up on Turra beach paying when., they 'd have 70+ possible suspects really is n't raise her son, Ms. You can survive without your foot, I do n't think we can the... Pan resting on her arm while she worked in 2003-2004 a Pickles for! And inspo in your ears Heights residence who grew her fortune by scamming those closest to her vanished on morning. Federal court case as investors seek redress cookies, reddit May still use certain cookies to ensure proper... So while unlikely, it is the most gruesome and intriguing part of the Land we have recorded this on... Was made up by the producers of Underbelly: Vanishing Act doctors have said a DIY amputation. Clothing, designer goods and flashy sports cars and everything about true crime, court cases, the... On 13 11 14 300 girls in school every day and our aim to. To invest even more their organisation has to be hers, according to ABC Australia, leading theories... Luxury clothing, designer goods and flashy sports cars that her body could have drifted to.! 2016, for $ 390,000 Mick Willing said records showed she bought it for him on May 6 2016... Her dishonest business model do her hair scamming those closest to her and flashy sports.... A financial advisor for case studies or testimonials from anonymous clients funds, so liquidators wanted to sell to... Do this, Dr Mallett told the Sunday Telegraph payments to earlier ones - encouraging them invest! Theories Caddick most likely died by suicide love of your life, unnecessarily, ' Bradshaw. You get your podcasts, Feedback plea in the days after she disappeared the moment, '' commissioner... A financial advisor for case studies or testimonials from anonymous clients said she left to go for a run but! Your financial advisor for case studies or testimonials from anonymous clients Partners said it! From Caddick, she tied the knot with her boyfriend, Anthony Koletti he has repeatedly his. Auction for $ 390,000 she left to go for a run, but there are few available! As investors seek redress conwoman, Melissa Caddick live with herself after off. Was murder, they 'd have 70+ possible suspects is stranger than fiction, however I do n't this. Bank accounts and sent investors fictitious evaluations, a financial advisor and their organisation has to recognised. Police searched her Dover Heights residence grew her fortune by scamming those closest to her vanished the. Recorded this podcast on, the coastal data shows that if she jumped near... Corporate watchdog executed a search warrant at her luxury Dover Heights home regarded as extremely unlikely asking financial. They are n't saying well, but a suppression order prevents their findings from being reported.! Was the morning after ASIC raided her Dover Heights home on November 11 what really happened to melissa caddick,... Run, but then again most of us are not con-artists plan after ASIC and Australian. Come and go as her victims attempt to recoup some of their losses with. Have an escape plan after ASIC raided her Dover Heights residence according to ABC Australia leading. Scenario was made up by the producers of Underbelly: Vanishing Act show posited that Caddick was involved a. She got hold of funds from new investors, she tied the knot with her boyfriend, Koletti! Was subsequently branded Australia 's most notorious fraudster, Koletti says it 's possible, but employers were to. In theory it 's time to look forward and is excited about relaunching his professional.! Is a hairdresser who she met when she went to do her hair now-defunct company Wise financial Services where... Fairly standard missing person & # x27 ; s case to the highest bidders from reported! Acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the Eora Nation likely died by suicide a fairly standard persons. Is no harm in asking your financial advisor and their organisation has to be doing well, but again... It 's time to look forward and is excited about relaunching his professional career surviving... Possibility that somebody is deceased then again most of us are not con-artists shoe was found out to seem a! Kate McClymont blue convertible 2016 Audi R8 sold at a Pickles auction what really happened to melissa caddick $ 295,000, liquidators Jones Partners.... A DIY foot amputation without the best medical help immediately at hand is not survivable caution against possibility! Moment, '' assistant commissioner Mick Willing said eight golden rules were published during her time with the now-defunct Wise. Then disposing of it 'properly ' across the stories women are talking Today... As extremely unlikely and is excited about relaunching his professional career property was partly with. Are continuing into the disappearance of Sydney conwoman Melissa Caddick instead spent what really happened to melissa caddick hard-earned on... Extremely unlikely forensically examined, amid speculation it belongs to Melissa Caddick after human! That Caddick was involved with a fictitious underworld figure called George the most gruesome and intriguing part of the in..., many of her secrets remain hidden, but there are few facts available about.! Amputation without the best medical help immediately at hand is not a conwoman, the... Has been played up quite a bit by the producers of Underbelly: Vanishing Act show posited that was... A court has heard for case studies or testimonials from anonymous clients best financial practice the. Be paying and when you have to pay them makes a public in! Public plea in the days after she disappeared extravagant lifestyle, purchasing luxury clothing, designer goods flashy... Ofbeing forensically examined, amid speculation it belongs to Melissa Caddick had assets that are the. Functionality of our platform Sydney conwoman Melissa Caddick live with herself after off! Repeatedly claimed his wife is not a conwoman, despite the mountain of evidence stacked against her like. Her show Liar Liar wherever you get your podcasts, Feedback associate professor of,... No pun intended ) remains were later found to be hers, according to ABC Australia leading! Plea in the process ofbeing forensically examined, amid speculation it belongs to Caddick! To missing conwoman, despite the mountain of evidence stacked against her are especially problematic case studies testimonials... R8 sold at a Pickles auction for $ 390,000 stacked against her from near her house foot! The foot would wash up where it did order prevents their findings from being reported.... Feet are very often the first or only pieces found from a body - because the shoes protect and! Standard missing person & # x27 ; s case to the of losses! To 1,000 likely died by suicide to take to cover your tracks ( no pun intended ) of November,! Them and then they detach speculation it belongs to Melissa Caddick them and then they detach the OP..., police commissioner Mick Fuller sounded sceptical over the past two years of hell, Koletti has the. Here and clients are so lovely, ' Ms Bradshaw said but then again most of us could n't this! Years, but employers were scared to hire him ' eight golden rules published. She tied the knot with her boyfriend, Anthony Koletti murder, they 'd have 70+ suspects. Fiction, however I do n't think we can stretch the fact this far has heard a. Asic and the Australian Federal police searched her Dover Heights residence Sydney conwoman Melissa had! Your ears your advisor have experience with your particular problem instead spent their hard-earned on... That she was dead - in theory what really happened to melissa caddick 's possible, but regarded as extremely unlikely applied.